Data Category: ( SI-Exp) Spin Independent - Experimental Limits
Result
Plot Colour and Plot Style
Source of Information/Reference
CDMS II (Soudan) Low Threshold Result, Spin Independent Ge (2011)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1011.2482v1 [astro-ph.CO]
CDMS: 2009 Ge
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Announced 17Dec2009, arXiv:0912.3592
CDMS: Soudan 2004-2009 Ge
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Announced 17Dec2009, Science 327, p. 1619, arXiv:0912.3592
CDMS-Edelweiss Combined Limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. D 84, (2011) 011102; arXiv:1105.3377v2
CDMS SUF Low Threshold (December 2010)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
CDMS-II (Soudan Silicon SI Result, R123-124 upper limit)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1304.3706
CDMS-II (Soudan Silicon SI Result, R123-128 combined upper limit)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Announced 13 April 2013, APS April Meeting arXiv:1304.3706 , arXiv:1304.4279
CDMS-II (Soudan Silicon SI Result, R125-128, contour, 68% C.L.)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Announced 13 April 2013, APS April Meeting arXiv:1304.4279
CDMS-II (Soudan Silicon SI Result, R125-128, contour 90% C.L.)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Announced 13 April 2013, APS April Meeting arXiv:1304.4279
CDMS-II (Soudan Silicon SI Result, R125-128, contour, 95% C.L.)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Announced 13 April 2013, APS April Meeting arXiv:1304.4279
CDMS-II (Soudan Silicon SI Result, R125-128, contour, 99% C.L.)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Announced 13 April 2013, APS April Meeting arXiv:1304.4279
CDMS-II (Soudan Silicon SI Result, R125-128 upper limit)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1304.4279
CRESST-II upper limit (2009) on coherent WIMP-nucleon cross section
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arxiv:0906.03290
CRESST-II 1-Sigma Allowed Region, 730kg-days data
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Results from the 730 kg days of the CRESST-II Dark Matter Search (arXiv:1109.0702 )
CRESST-II 2-sigma Allowed Region part 1, 730kg-days data
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Results from the 730 kg days of the CRESST-II Dark Matter Search (arXiv:1109.0702 )
CoGENT 90% C.L. WIMP exclusion limits, March 2010
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1002.4703v2 [astro-ph.CO]
CoGeNT+DAMA region, 90% C.L., Hooper PRD 2010
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev.Lett.107:051301,2011 DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.051301 , arXiv:1104.3088v1
CoGeNT+DAMA region, 90% C.L., Hooper PRD 2010
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev.Lett.107:051301,2011 DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.051301 , arXiv:1104.3088v1
CoGeNT region,Hooper PRD 2010, 90% C.L.
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev.Lett.107:051301,2011 DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.051301 , arXiv:1104.3088v1
CoGeNT region, 99% C.L., Hooper PRD 2010
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev.Lett.107:051301,2011 DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.051301 , arXiv:1104.3088v1
CoGeNT Annual Modulation Search, PRL 107 (2011), Region of Interest
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Search for an Annual Modulation in a p-Type Point Contact Germanium Dark Matter Detector (http://prl.aps.org/pdf/PRL/v107/i14/e141301)
90% C.L. Boundaries of CoGENT-compatible WIMP model, shown in Fig. 4 (March 2010)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1002.4703v2 [astro-ph.CO]
DAMA/LIBRA 2008 5sigma, no ion channeling
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
DAMA/LIBRA first results [EPJ C56 (2008), 333, arXiv:0804.2741 ], as interpreted in Savage et al., arXiv:0808.3607v2 (χ2 g.o.f., Fig. 10)
DAMA/I 90% C.L. favored by DAMA, from Fig.5 in Xenon 100 Results (2011)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1104.2549
DAMA region, 90% C.L., Hooper PRD 2010
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev.Lett.107:051301,2011 DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.051301 , arXiv:1104.3088v1
DAMA region, 99% C.L., Hooper PRD 2010
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev.Lett.107:051301,2011 DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.051301 , arXiv:1104.3088v1
Edelweiss II first result, 144 kg-days interleaved Ge
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0912.0805
Edelweiss II Final result (March 25 2011)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1103.4070 (384 kg-day Exposure)
CoGeNT, 68% C.L., Hooper, Kelso, & Buckley (2011)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Toward a Consistent Picture for CRESST, CoGeNT, and DAMA (arXiv:1110.5338v1 )
CoGeNT region,Hooper PRD 2010, 90% C.L.
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev.Lett.107:051301,2011 DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.051301 , arXiv:1104.3088v1
IceCube 2009 indirect SI (assuming annihilation to W+ W- )
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Abbasi et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 201302 (2009), arXiv:0902.2460
IceCube 2009 indirect SI (assuming annihilation to b-bbar)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Abbasi et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 201302 (2009), arXiv:0902.2460
KIMS 2007 - 3409 kg-days CsI
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0704.0423
ROSEBUD 2001 Exclusion Limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
S. Cebrian et al., astro-ph/0004292
TEXONO 0.337 kg-d, Dec 2007
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0712.1645
Xenon100 C.L. Boundaries, flat priors (68% Bayesian)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Global fits of the cMSSM including the first LHC and XENON100 data, G. Bertone,et.al.(2011), arXiv 1107.1715
NAIAD 2005 final result
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:hep-ex/0504031
WARP 2.3L, 96.5 kg-days 40 keV threshold
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Astropart. Phys. 28, 495 (2007), astro-ph/0701286 (40 keV threshold, 5 events 40-54 keV assumed to be background)
WARP 2.3L, 96.5 kg-days 55 keV threshold
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Astropart. Phys. 28, 495 (2007), astro-ph/0701286 (no events above 55 keV threshold)
XENON100 2010 (161 kg-d)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1005.0380
XENON10 2007, measured Leff from Xe cube
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. C. 79 (2009), 045807; arXiv:0810.0274
XENON10 2007 (Net 136 kg-d)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 100 (2008), 021303; arXiv:0706.0039
Xenon 100 (2011)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1104.2549v2 [astro-ph.CO]
Xenon10, S2 only (2011)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev.Lett.107:051301,2011 DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.051301 , arXiv:1104.3088v1
Edelweiss II Low Threshold Result (5 Sept 2012)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. D 86 051701(R) (2012), arXiv:1207.1815 (113 kg.d exposure)
XENON 100 Results from 225 live days of data presented at IDM
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1207.5988v1
Data Category: ( SI-Th) Spin Independent - Theory
Result
Plot Colour and Plot Style
Source of Information/Reference
Phenomenological MSSM (Arbey et. al.), 2013, 99.5% C.L.
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Arbey et. al, arXiv:1211.4004
BayesFITS (Fowlie et al.), 2012, 68% C.L.
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1206.0264
BayesFITS (Fowlie et al.), 2012, 95% C.L.
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1206.0264
DAMA/I 90% C.L. favored by DAMA, from Fig.5 in Xenon 100 Results (2011)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:1104.2549
A. Pierce, Finely Tuned MSSM
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Submitted to ArXiv, hep-ph/0406144
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; 68%; Profile likelihood
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; 95% ; Profile likelihood
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; 99% C.L.; Profile likelihood
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; 68% C.L.; No XENON; flat priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; 95% No Xenon, flat priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; 99%, no Xenon100, flat priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; No Xenon, 68% C.L., log priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; No Xenon; 95% C.L., log priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; No Xenon; 99% C.L., log priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; with Xenon 68%; Profile likelihood
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; with Xenon 95%; Profile likelihood
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; with Xenon 99%; Profile likelihood
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; with Xenon 68% ; flat priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; with Xenon 95%; flat priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; with Xenon 99%; flat priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; with Xenon 68% ; log priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; with Xenon 95%; log priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive: arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
Strege, Bertone, Cerdeno, Fornasa, Ruiz de Austri, & Trotta 2011; with Xenon 99%; log priors
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Strege, G. Bertone, D.G. Cerdeno, M. Fornasa, R. Ruiz de Austri & R. Trotta (2011), e-print archive:arXiv.org/abs/1112.4192
rSUGRA, M3=M1, 0.6
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
A. Birkedal-Hansen and B. Nelson, hep-ph/0211071.pdf
rSUGRA, M3=M2, 0.6
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
A. Birkedal-Hansen and B. Nelson, hep-ph/0211071.pdf
Trotta et al 2008, CMSSM Bayesian: 68% contour
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0809.3792
Trotta et al 2008, CMSSM Bayesian: 95% contour
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0809.3792
Data Category: ( SI-Proj) Spin Independent - Projected limit
Result
Plot Colour and Plot Style
Source of Information/Reference
CUORE0 (3yr) 117 kg-y Te02 Expected Sensitivity
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Conference for the Identification of Dark Matter 2010 http://arxiv.org/abs/1102.3564 CUORE Contact Marco Vignati, marco.vignati@roma1.infn.it
CUORE (5yr) 3.7 Ton-y Te02, Expected Sensitivity
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Conference Identification of Dark Matter 2010 http://arxiv.org/abs/1102.3564 CUORE Contact Marco Vignati, marco.vignati@roma1.infn.it
LUX/ZEP 20 tonne LXe Proj (48 tonne-year)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
LUX/ZEP III Collaboration, July 2008, Gaitskell, Brown University
LZ20T LXe Proj (10 evt sens,13t-kdy)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
LUX/ZEP III Collaboration, July 2008, Gaitskell, Brown University
LZ20T LXe Proj (1 evt sens,13t-kdy)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
LUX/ZEP III Collaboration, July 2008, Gaitskell, Brown University
LUX/ZEP 3 tonne LXe Proj (3 tonne-year)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
LUX/ZEP III Collaboration, July 2008, Gaitskell, Brown University
LUX 300 kg LXe Projection (Jul 2007)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Gaitskell, Brown University
SuperCDMS - 100 kg at SNOLAB
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
SuperCDMS Proposal
SuperCDMS - 15 kg at Soudan
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
SuperCDMS Proposal
WARP 140kg (proj)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
McKinsey Fermilab May 2007
XENON100 projected sensitivity: 6000 kg-d, 5-30 keV, 45% eff.
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Kaixuan Ni, private communication 090516
XENON100 upgrade projected sensitivity: 60,000 kg-d, 5-30 keV, 45% eff.
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Kaixuan Ni, private communication 090516
XENON 1T Projected (2017)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
The XENON1T Experiment at LNGS , presented by E. Aprile at Columbia University 2/24/12(DM2012)
XMASS 800kg, FV 0.5 ton-year
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Minamino, Akihiro. XMASS experiment. KEKPH meeting at KEK, 3 March 2004
Data Category: ( SD-Exp) Spin Dependent - Experimental Limits
Result
Plot Colour and Plot Style
Source of Information/Reference
CDMS II Low Threshold Ge, 2010, Spin Dependent
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Results from a Low-Energy Analysis of the CDMS II Germanium Data, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106 131302 (2011) (arXiv:1011.2482v3 [astro-ph.CO], http://prl.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v106/i13/e131302)
CDMS Soudan 2004-2009 Ge SD-neutron
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Announced 17Dec2009, see http://cdms.berkeley.edu
CDMS Soudan 2004-2009 Ge SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Announced 17Dec2009, see http://cdms.berkeley.edu
COUPP 2008 SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Behnke et al., Science 319 p. 933 (2008)
DAMA/LIBRA 2008 3sigma SDn, no ion channeling
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
DAMA/LIBRA first results [EPJ C56 (2008), 333, arXiv:0804.2741 ], as interpreted in Savage et al., arXiv:0808.3607v2 (χ2 g.o.f., Fig. 18)
DAMA/LIBRA 2008 3sigma SDn, with ion channeling
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
DAMA/LIBRA first results [EPJ C56 (2008), 333, arXiv:0804.2741 ], as interpreted in Savage et al., arXiv:0808.3607v2 (χ2 g.o.f., Fig. 19)
DAMA/LIBRA 2008 3sigma SDp, no ion channeling
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
DAMA/LIBRA first results [EPJ C56 (2008), 333, arXiv:0804.2741 ], as interpreted in Savage et al., arXiv:0808.3607v2 (χ2 g.o.f., Fig. 14)
DAMA/LIBRA 2008 3sigma SDp, with ion channeling
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
DAMA/LIBRA first results [EPJ C56 (2008), 333, arXiv:0804.2741 ], as interpreted in Savage et al., arXiv:0808.3607v2 (χ2 g.o.f., Fig. 15)
IceCube 2009 indirect SD-proton (assuming annihilation to W+ W- )
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Abbasi et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 201302 (2009), arXiv:0902.2460
IceCube 2009 indirect SD-proton (assuming annihilation to b-bbar)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Abbasi et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 201302 (2009), arXiv:0902.2460
KIMS 2007 - 3409 kg-days CsI SD-neutron
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0704.0423
KIMS 2007 - 3409 kg-days CsI SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0704.0423
NAIAD 2005 Final SD-neutron
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
G. J. Alner et al. [UKDMC], Phys. Lett. B 616 (2005), 17.
NAIAD 2005 Final SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
G. J. Alner et al. [UKDMC], Phys. Lett. B 616 (2005), 17.
PICASSO SD-neutron (2005)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
M. Barnabe-Heider et al., Phys. Lett. B624 (2005), 186-194.
PICASSO SD-proton (2009)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
S.Archambault et al., arXiv:0907.0307.
SIMPLE SD-neutron (2005)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
T.A. Girard et al., Phys. Lett. B621 (2005), 233-238.
SIMPLE SD-proton (2005)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
T.A. Girard et al., Phys. Lett. B621 (2005), 233-238.
SuperK indirect SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
S. Desai et al., Phys. Rev. D 70 (2004), 083523.
Tokyo 2005 CaF2 SD-neutron
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Lett. B 633 (2006) 195-200, astro-ph/0510390
Tokyo 2005 CaF2, SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Lett. B 633 (2006) 195-200, astro-ph/0510390
Tokyo 2001 4.1 kg-day LiF, SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Astropart. Phys. 19 (2003) 135-144, astro-ph/0204411
Tokyo 2002 3.38 kg-day NaF, SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Lett. B 572 (2003) 145-151, astro-ph/0306365
XENON10 SD-neutron
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 101 (2008), 091301; arXiv:0805.2939
XENON10 SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 101 (2008), 091301; arXiv:0805.2939
Data Category: ( SI-Exp) Spin Independent - Experimental Limits
Result
Plot Colour and Plot Style
Source of Information/Reference
CDMS Feb. 2000 ver. sub. to PRL
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 84 (2000) p.5699, abstract
CDMS Mar. 2002, QI, bkgd subtracted, with Si data
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Submitted to PRD, astro-ph/0203500
CDMS Mar. 2002, QI, bkgd subtracted, no Si data
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Submitted to PRD, astro-ph/0203500
CDMS Mar. 2002, QI, bkgd subtracted, expected sensitivity
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Submitted to PRD, astro-ph/0203500
CDMS (SUF) Mar. 2002, Qshared, bkgd subtracted, with Si data
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev. D66 (2002) 122003,astro-ph/0203500
CDMS Mar. 2002, Qshared, bkgd subtracted, no Si data
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Submitted to PRD, astro-ph/0203500
CDMS (SUF) Mar. 2002, Qshared, no bkgd subtraction
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev. D66 (2002) 122003,astro-ph/0203500
CDMS Mar. 2002, Qshared, bkgd subtracted, expected sensitivity
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Submitted to PRD, astro-ph/0203500
CDMS Mar. 2002, QI, no bkgd subtraction
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Submitted to PRD, astro-ph/0203500
CDMS June 2003, expected sensitivity bkgd subtracted
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Submitted to PRL, hep-ex/0306001
CDMS June 2003, expected sensitivity with no subtraction
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Submitted to PRL, hep-ex/0306001
CDMS (SUF) 2003, 28 kg-days Ge, bkgd subtr
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev. D68 (2003) 082002, hep-ex/0306001
CDMS (SUF) 2003, 28 kg-days Ge, no subtr
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys.Rev. D68 (2003) 082002, hep-ex/0306001
CDMS (Soudan) 2004 Blind 53 raw kg-days Ge
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004), 211301astro-ph/0405033
CDMS (Soudan) 2004 Not Blind 53 raw kg-days Ge
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004), 211301astro-ph/0405033
CDMS (Soudan) 2005 Ge (10 keV threshold)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 96 (2006), 011302, astro-ph/0509259
CDMS (Soudan) 2005 Si (7 keV threshold)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 96 (2006), 011302, astro-ph/0509259
CDMS (Soudan) 2004 + 2005 Ge (7 keV threshold)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 96 (2006), 011302, astro-ph/0509259
CDMS 2008 Ge
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 102 (2009) 011301, arXiv:0802.3530
CDMS 2004+2005 reanalysis Ge (5 keV threshold)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 102 (2009) 011301, arXiv:0802.3530
CDMS Soudan 2004-2008 Ge
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 102 (2009) 011301, arXiv:0802.3530; updated 2009 for corrected detector masses
CRESST 2004 10.7 kg-day CaWO4
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Astropart. Phys. 23 (2005) 325-339
CRESST 2007 60 kg-day CaWO4
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0805.4705
CRESST - Gran Sasso Run 28 (CaWO4 9 kg-days) Preliminary Analysis (Apr 2004)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
CoGeNT 8.4 kg-d, July 2008
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0807.0879
DAMA 2000 58k kg-days NaI Ann. Mod. 3sigma w/DAMA 1996
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
DAMA/NaI-0 to 4 combined, Phys. Lett. B480 (2000) 23-31, abstract
DAMA 2000 58k kg-days NaI Ann.Mod. 3sigma,w/o DAMA 1996 limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
DAMA/NaI-1 to 4 combined, Phys. Lett. B480 (2000) 23-31, abstract
DAMA/LIBRA 2008 5sigma, with ion channeling
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
DAMA/LIBRA first results [EPJ C56 (2008), 333, arXiv:0804.2741 ], as interpreted in Savage et al., arXiv:0808.3607v2 (χ2 g.o.f., Fig. 11)
ELEGANT V NaI spin indep. limit, OTO COSMO Observatory
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Presented by K. Fushimi at DM2000, Marina del Rey, pdf
Edelweiss, 4.5 kg-days Ge(320g) June 2001 limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
astro-ph/0106094 Improved limit from Nov00->Mar01 run
Edelweiss, 11.7 kg-days Ge 2000+2002 limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
astro-ph/0206271 Improved limit for 11.7 kg-days exposure - combined 2000 and 2002 data sets (submitted to PLB)
Edelweiss, 32 kg-days Ge 2000+2002+2003 limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Preliminary improved limit for 32 kg-days exposure - combined 2000,2002 and 2003 data sets (Chardin)
Edelweiss Al2O3
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Astroparticle Physics 6 (1996) 35-43, abstract
Edelweiss I final limit, 62 kg-days Ge 2000+2002+2003 limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:astro-ph/0503265
Heidelberg-Moscow, 1994
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Heidelberg Moscow, 1998
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Physics Reports 307 (1998) 301-308, abstract
IGEX 2002 Nov limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
astro-ph/0211535, abstract
IGEX 2002 limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
hep-ex/0110061, abstract
IGEX exclusion limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Presented by F. T. Avignone III at DM2000, Marina del Rey, pdf
KIMS 2005 - 237 kg-days CsI
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Lett. B 633 (2006), 201-208 ( arXiv )
MIBETA exclusion limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Presented by S. Pirro at DM2000, Marina del Rey, pdf
Milan TeO2
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Approximation, contact collaboration
Modane NaI
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Astroparticle Physics 11 (1999) 287-302, abstract
Saclay exclusion limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Presented by G. Gerbier at DM2000, Marina del Rey, pdf
Saclay
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Talk by Morales at TAUP99, pdf
NAIAD 2002 result
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
M. Carson talk at DM2002, Marina del Rey
UKDMC
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Approximation, contact collaboration
XENON10 2007 (Net 136 kg-d)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
As announced APS April 2007, arXiv:0706.0039
XENON10 2007 (Net 136 kg-d, BG Subtract)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Announced APS April 2007
ZEPLIN I Preliminary 2002 result
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Presented at IDM2002,York,UK (Awaiting final limit in refereed publication)
ZEPLIN I (2005)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Astroparticle Physics 23 (2005), 444-462
ZEPLIN III (Dec 2008) result
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0812.1150v1 [astro-ph] (847 kg-days)
ZEPLIN II (Jan 2007) result
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
astro-ph/0701858 (225 kg-days, 5-20 keVee, 29 events, bg subtracted to 10.4 evts)
Data Category: ( SI-Th) Spin Independent - Theory
Result
Plot Colour and Plot Style
Source of Information/Reference
Arrenberg et al. Universal Extra Dimensions, B_1
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
S. Arrenberg et al., Phys. Rev. D 78 056002 (2008); arXiv:0805.4210
Universal Extra Dimensions, B_H
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
S. Arrenberg et al., Phys. Rev. D 78 056002 (2008); arXiv:0805.4210
Baer et. al well-tempered neutralinos, hyperbolic branch / focus point
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
JCAP 0701 (2007) 017; arXiv: hep-ph/0611387
Baer et. al well-tempered neutralinos (mixed higgsino, Omegah^2~0.1)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
JCAP 0701 (2007) 017; arXiv: hep-ph/0611387
Baer et. al 2003
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Baltz and Gondolo, 2004, Markov Chain Monte Carlos
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv: hep-ph/0407039
Baltz and Gondolo, 2004, Markov Chain Monte Carlos (1 sigma)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
hep-ph/0407039
Chattopadhyay et. al Theory results - post WMAP
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:hep-ph/0310228
Cirelli, Fornengo and Strumia: Minimal Dark Matter
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Nucl. Phys. B753 (2006), hep-ph/0512090
Davoudiasl/Kitano/Li/Murayama (Scalar KG field) 2004
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
hep-ph/0405097
Ellis et. al 2005 CMSSM (mu>0, pion Sigma=64 MeV)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:hep-ph/0502001, Fig. 3d
Ellis et. al 2005 LEEST (mu>0, pion Sigma=64 MeV)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:hep-ph/0502001, Fig. 5d
Ellis et. al 2005 NUHM (mu>0, pion Sigma=64 MeV)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:hep-ph/0502001 , Fig. 6d
Ellis et. al Theory region post-LEP benchmark points
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Original astro-ph/0110225 , discussion astro-ph/0304183 , update of points hep-ph/0306219
Guidice and Romanino, 2004, mu > 0
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
hep-ph/0406088
Guidice and Romanino, 2004, mu < 0
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
hep-ph/0406088
Kim/Nihei/Roszkowski/Ruiz de Austri 2002 JHEP
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
JHEP 0212 (2002) 034 / hep-ph0208069
Lahanas and Nanopoulos 2003
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv ref:hep-ph/0303130
Masiero, Profumo and Ullio: general Split SUSY
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
hep-ph/0412058
Ruiz de Austri/Trotta/Roszkowski 2006, CMSSM Markov Chain Monte Carlos: 68% contour
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
hep-ph/0602028
Ruiz de Austri/Trotta/Roszkowski 2006, CMSSM Markov Chain Monte Carlos: 95% contour
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
hep-ph/0602028
Roszkowski/Ruiz de Austri/Trotta 2007, CMSSM Markov Chain Monte Carlos (mu<0): 68% contour
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
JHEP 0707:075 (2007), arXiv:0705.2012
Roszkowski/Ruiz de Austri/Trotta 2007, CMSSM Markov Chain Monte Carlos (mu<0): 95% contour
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
JHEP 0707:075 (2007), arXiv:0705.2012
Roszkowski/Ruiz de Austri/Trotta 2007, CMSSM Markov Chain Monte Carlos (mu>0): 68% contour
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
JHEP 0707:075 (2007), arXiv:0705.2012
Roszkowski/Ruiz de Austri/Trotta 2007, CMSSM Markov Chain Monte Carlos (mu>0): 95% contour
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
JHEP 0707:075 (2007), arXiv:0705.2012
Bottino et al., hep-ph/0001309 SUSY
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Points supplied by Nicolao Fornengo from hep-ph/0001309
Bottino et al., hep-ph/0001309 SUSY (DAMA Region)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
(DAMA Region) Points supplied by Nicolao Fornengo from hep-ph/0001309
Baltz and Gondolo, spin indep. sigma in MSSM, with muon g-2 constraint
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Baltz and Gondolo, hep-ph/0102147
Ellis et al., Spin indep. sigma in CMSSM
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Ellis et al., hep-ph/0001005
Ellis et al., Spin indep. sigma in MSSM
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Ellis et al., hep-ph/0007113
Corsetti & Nath, mSUGRA hepph0003186
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
From hep-ph/0003186
Gondolo et al. SUSY (Gaugino-like Models)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Paolo Gondolo
Gondolo et al. SUSY (Higgsino-like Models)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Paolo Gondolo
Gondolo et al. SUSY (Mixed Models)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Paolo Gondolo
Data Category: ( SI-Proj) Spin Independent - Projected limit
Result
Plot Colour and Plot Style
Source of Information/Reference
CDMSII (Projected) Development ZBG
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Contact Richard Schnee, CWRU
SuperCDMS (Projected) Phase A
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Contact Richard Schnee, CWRU
SuperCDMS (Projected) Phase B
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Contact Richard Schnee, CWRU
SuperCDMS (Projected) Phase C
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Contact Richard Schnee, CWRU
SuperCDMS (Projected) 2-ST@Soudan
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
SuperCDMS Proposal
SuperCDMS (Projected) 25kg (7-ST@Snolab)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
SuperCDMS Proposal
CUORICINO projected exclusion limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Presented by F. T. Avignone III at DM2000, Marina Del Rey, pdf
DEAP CLEAN 1000kg FV (proj)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
McKinsey Fermilab May 2007
DEAP CLEAN 150kg FV (proj)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
McKinsey Fermilab May 2007
DEAP CLEAN 25kg FV (proj)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
McKinsey Fermilab May 2007
DMRC projection for 100kg CsI, 10cpd
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
S.K. Kim talk at the DM2002, Marina del Rey
DMRC projection for 100kg CsI, 1cpd
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
S.K. Kim talk at the DM2002, Marina del Rey
Edelweiss Ge, projected
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Approximation, contact collaboration
Edelweiss 1 projection
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
O. Martineau talk at DM2002, Marina del Rey
Edelweiss 2 projection
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
O. Martineau talk at DM2002, Marina del Rey
Target Sensitivity Range 10-45 - 10-46 cm2
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Target Band for Projected Sensitivty (Gaitskell)
Target Sensitivity Range 10-46 - 10-47 cm2
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Target Band for Projected Sensitivty (Gaitskell)
GEDEON projection
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
hep-ex/0110061 , abstract
GeODM - 1.5T at DUSEL
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
S. Golwala, personal communication
Genius Test Facility projected limit, 2001, energy threshold 11 keV
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
L. Baudis et al., hep-ex/0012022
Genius Test Facility projected limit, 2001, energy threshold 2 keV
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
L. Baudis et al., hep-ex/0012022
Genino projected exclusion limit, DM2000
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Presented by B. Majorovits at DM2000, Marina Del Rey, pdf
Heidelberg - Genius, projected
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Physics Reports 307 (1998) 301-308, abstract
Heidelberg DMS, projected
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Physics Reports 307 (1998) 301-308, abstract
IGEX 2002 projection, 0.04 ev/keV/kg/day
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
hep-ex/0110061, abstract
IGEX 2002 projection, 0.1 ev/keV/kg/day
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
hep-ex/0110061, abstract
IGEX projected exclusion limit (for 1kgyr)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Presented by F. T. Avignone III at DM2000, Marina del Rey pdf
KIMS projected - 2350kg-years CsI
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Lett. B 633 (2006), 201-208 (arXiv )
NAIAD spin indep. projected limit, 12 p.e./keV with 100 kg-yrs exposure
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
N.J.C. Spooner et al., Phys. Let. B 473 (2000) 330, abstract
ROSEBUD 2001, Projected Exclusion Limit
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
S. Cebrian et al., astro-ph/0004292
XENON 1T projected sensitivity: 3 ton-yr, 2-30 keV, 45% eff.
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Kaixuan Ni, private communication 090516
ZEPLIN 1, projection for 8 months
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
S. Hart talk at DM2002, Marina del Rey
ZEPLIN 2 projection
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
H. Wang talk at DM2002, Marina del Rey
ZEPLINIII(yr 1) Proj. Sens.
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Araujo et al. (2006) Astropart. Physics, 26, 140-153 (2006); Akimov et al. (2007) Astropart. Physics, 27, 46-60 (2007), Sumner et al. (2006) Proposal October 2006
ZEPLINIII(yr 3,with PMT upgrade) Proj. Sens.
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Araujo et al. (2006) Astropart. Physics, 26, 140-153 (2006); Akimov et al. (2007) Astropart. Physics, 27, 46-60 (2007), Sumner et al. (2006) Proposal October 2006
ZEPLIN 4/MAX projected (2004)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
H. Wang talk at DM2004, Marina del Rey
Data Category: ( SD-Exp) Spin Dependent - Experimental Limits
Result
Plot Colour and Plot Style
Source of Information/Reference
CDMS Soudan 2004+2005 Ge SD-neutron
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006), 011102, astro-ph/0509269
CDMS Soudan 2004+2005 Ge SD-neutron (Ressell form factor)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006), 011102, astro-ph/0509269
CDMS Soudan 2004-2008 Ge SD-neutron
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. Lett. 102 (2009) 011301, arXiv:0802.3530; updated 2009 for corrected detector masses
CDMS Soudan 2004+2005 Ge SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006), 011102, astro-ph/0509269
CDMS Soudan 2004+2005 Ge SD-proton (Ressell form factor)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006), 011102, astro-ph/0509269
CDMS Soudan 2004-2008 Ge SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0802.3530; updated 2009 for corrected detector masses
CDMS Soudan 2004+2005 Si SD-neutron
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006), 011102, astro-ph/0509269
CDMS Soudan 2004+2005 Si SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006), 011102, astro-ph/0509269
CRESST II CaO SD-neutron (est.)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Savage et al., astro-ph/0408346
CRESST II W SD-neutron (est.)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Savage et al., astro-ph/0408346
CRESST I SD-neutron (est.)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Savage et al., astro-ph/0408346
CRESST I SD-proton (est.)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Savage et al., astro-ph/0408346
DAMA 2003 NaI SD-neutron (est.)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Savage et al., astro-ph/0408346
DAMA 2003 NaI SD-proton (est.)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
C. Savage et al., astro-ph/0408346
ELEGANT V NaI spin dep. exclusion limit (OTO COSMO Observatory)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Presented by K. Fushimi at DM2000, Marina del Rey pdf
Edelweiss Al2O3
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Astroparticle Physics 6 (1996) 35-43, abstract
Edelweiss SD-neutron
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
V. Sanglard et al., Phys. Lett. B616 (2005), 25-30 ( arXiv:astro-ph/0412061 )
Edelweiss SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
A. Benoit et al., Phys. Lett. B616 (2005), 25-30 (arXiv:astro-ph/0412061 )
Modane NaI
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Astroparticle Physics 11 (1999) 287-302, abstract
PICASSO SD-proton (2005)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
M. Barnabe-Heider et al., Phys. Lett. B624 (2005), 186-194.
SIMPLE SD-neutron (2004)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
F. Giuliani and T.A. Girard, Phys. Lett. B588 (2004), 151-154.
SIMPLE SD-proton (2004)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
F. Giuliani and T.A. Girard, Phys. Lett. B588 (2004), 151-154.
Saclay
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Talk by Morales at TAUP99, pdf
TOKYO, Spin Dependent Exclusion Limit, LiF 15m w.e.
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
W. Ootani et al., hep-ex/9903034
UKDMC NaI, from I data
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 70 (1999) 74-78, abstract
UKDMC NaI, from Na data
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 70 (1999) 74-78, abstract
UKDMC NaI, from combined Na and I data
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
Nuclear Physics B (Proc. Suppl.) 70 (1999) 74-78, abstract
ZEPLIN I SD-neutron (preliminary)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
V. Kudryavtsev, IDM2004
ZEPLIN I SD-proton (preliminary)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
V. Kudryavtsev, IDM2004
ZEPLIN III SD-neutron (Bonn-CD)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0901.4348, Bonn-CD nuclear potential
ZEPLIN III SD-proton (Bonn-CD)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0901.4348, Bonn-CD nuclear potential
ZEPLIN III SD-neutron (Bonn-A)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0901.4348, Bonn-A nuclear potential
ZEPLIN III SD-proton (Bonn-A)
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0901.4348, Bonn-A nuclear potential
ZEPLIN II SD-neutron
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0708.1883
ZEPLIN II SD-proton
Red
LtR
DkR
Grn
LtG
DkG
Blu
LtB
DkB
Mag
Yel
Cyn
Wht
G10
G20
G30
G40
G50
G60
G70
G80
G90
Blk
Line
Dotted
Dash
Fill
Points
Crosses
Circles
Pluses
Asterisks
5-pt stars
6-pt stars
Triangles (up)
Triangles (down)
Triangles (left)
Triangles (right)
arXiv:0708.1883
Please consider giving the site, and us, a credit if you remove the
labels from the plot. Thanks.